Tuesday, May 31, 2005

U.S. Has Become a Gulag Under Bush Regime

By MARC MCDONALD

George W. Bush has labeled as "absurd" an Amnesty International report which recently described the Guantanamo detention camp as a "gulag of our times."

However, many of us feel that the America itself has turned into one great big gulag under Bush.

This is hardly an exaggeration. Millions of us have watched in dismay over the past five years as the Bush Cartel has transformed America into an oppressive, miserable place to live. We've watched as the Bush team has steadily chipped away at our freedoms since 9/11, via the Patriot Act and other measures that have increasingly imposed a police state in this country.

All of this might be more tolerable if we felt that the Bush team had come to power, fair and square, via the ballot. But millions of Americans harbor serious doubts as to whether the elections of 2000 and 2004 were legitimate at all.

Gulags, of course, are notable for the fact that their residents are compelled to toil long hours. And although the erosion of worker's rights in this country pre-dates Bush, it's a fact that the past five years have seen an unprecedented assault of the rights of working people. Americans are working longer hours for less pay than at any time since the notorious Gilded Age in the 19th century. In fact, today, Americans work by far the longest hours in the industrialized world.

Unions are under assault and decent jobs are increasingly scarce. Workers are having to juggle two and three jobs, simply to put food on the table. And average wages have declined under Bush (although CEO pay has soared).

Gulags are typically characterized by an all-encompassing sense of fear. And Bush's America is a place where fear is widespread. Workers, for one, are fearful that they'll lose their jobs. And workers who're fearful can be counted on to not try to form unions or demand improved wages and benefits.

One recent eye-opening poll revealed that 70 percent of workers who're non-unionized would join a union if they were able to. When the poll asked participants their main reason for not joining a union, workers responded that they were fearful of losing their jobs.

The Bush Cartel, of course, has shamelessly instilled a sense of fear in the country since 9/11. And fear is a powerful tool of control. In fact, it could be argued that fear is a principal lever of Bush's power. When people are fearful, they are compliant and less likely to question authority. The Patriot Act, a bill that shreds the U.S. Constitution, would likely have faced more opposition during its passage had the American people not been so consumed with fear.

Gulags have been traditionally used as a mechanism for repressing political opposition. The Bush team has, of course, succeeded brilliantly in brutally stifling its political opponents. Part of this is due to today's spineless Democrats. But the main factor that has enabled Bush's reign of terror has been a compliant media.

During our darkest hours of the past five years, when we needed a strong, questioning, independent media, we're really been let down by a gutless press that has refused to stand up to this administration and tell the people the truth.

Of course, gulags are mainly characterized by the incarceration of people. Once again, this pretty much sums up today's America: a country that has the highest prison population in the history of the world. In fact, prisons are big business these days in the U.S. It's an industry that's being increasingly privatized and becoming a cash cow for corporate America. Prison labor, too, is on the rise in the U.S., a phenomenon that's gotten zero coverage in the mainstream media (although our press never tires of blasting China for using prison labor).

An astonishing two million people are now behind bars in this country. To put that into perspective, consider that Japan (a nation with half our population) has less than 70,000 people behind bars.

Through America's mismanaged trade policies and U.S. corporations' profits-before-people philosophy, this nation has lost tens of millions of good-paying jobs over the past two decades. The once-mighty American middle class is all but extinct and we're seeing the rise of a large, increasingly desperate and hopeless underclass in this nation. It's clear that America's exploding prison population is directly tied to the polarization of U.S. society and the growing gulf between rich and poor.

Is it accurate to say that America is becoming a gulag under Bush? Here's one final sobering statistic I'd like to mention. If the exploding U.S. prison population continues to increase at the same rate it has over the past quarter century, then every single American will be either in prison, or working in the prison system, by the year 2150. Then, the U.S. really will be one gigantic gulag.

Saturday, April 30, 2005

CEO Pay Soared in 2004 as U.S. Economy Stumbled

By MARC MCDONALD

CEO pay continues to soar into the stratosphere, while wages for the average American worker stagnate.
Forbes magazine reports that the CEOs of America's 500 biggest companies received an aggregate 54 percent pay raise last year. As a group, their total compensation totaled $5.1 billion (compared with $3.3 billion in fiscal 2003).

Conservatives, no doubt, would argue that under America's free market system, these chief executives "earned" their pay. But did they?

Forbes, a publication not exactly considered to be in the progressive camp, seems to think otherwise.
The magazine says some CEOs "did so bad they should have paid their shareholders."

Take Peter Cartwright of Calpine, a maker of gas-fired power plants. Forbes reports that Calpine's average annual return to shareholders over the past six years has been minus 7 percent. During the same period, Cartwright pocketed an average annual $13 million.

America's CEOs are by far the highest paid CEOs of any nation on earth. Which begs a question: why?

The U.S. economy isn't exactly stellar at the moment. In fact, an increasing number of commentators warn that America's economy is facing a major crisis.

Our exploding fiscal and trade deficits are the highest that any developed nation has ever seen. America's once-vaunted manufacturing base has been hollowed out. And the dollar continues to crumble in value.

Exploding CEO pay is a relatively recent phenomenon in U.S. history. For example, in the 1960s, the average CEO earned around 40 times what the rank-and-file workers earned. Today the average CEO makes over 500 times what the average worker earns. And the gap continues to widen, year by year.

Like a magician pulling a rabbit out of a hat, conservatives are constantly coming up with reasons to justify soaring CEO pay. Here are three of my favorites:

CEOs create jobs. They create shareholder value. They have supposedly made the U.S. economy the strongest and most competitive in the world.

First of all, let's take a look at jobs. The past few years haven't exactly been a boon to job seekers in the U.S. Fewer and fewer jobs are being created these days. And the jobs that do exist are paying less and offer increasingly meager benefits. And American employees work the longest hours in the industrialized world, as author Juliet Schor pointed out in her book, The Overworked American.

Now, consider the issue of "shareholder value." The past few years haven't exactly been stellar for the stock market. But even the CEOs who preside over companies with sinking share value continue to pocket huge compensation packages.

Last, but not least: let's take a look at America's "competitiveness" these days.

A recurring mantra with America's mainstream and business press is that the U.S. is the most "competitive" economy in the world. A casual look at America's current trade figures, though, explodes this myth.

The fact is, America has the largest trade deficits of any First World nation in history. It seems to me that the U.S. has a difficult time these days creating products that other nations want to buy. Meanwhile, Americans line up to buy products from countries like Germany (which exceeds even China as the world's largest exporter) and Japan---despite the fact that average wages in those two countries are now higher than U.S. wage levels.

If U.S. corporations are really that "competitive" these days, it seems strange to me that America's CEOs seem to have a tough time making ends meet without corporate welfare.

Take Wal-Mart for example. The world's largest corporation (with over $286 billion in annual sales) cost American taxpayers over $1.5 billion in 2004, according to Walmartwatch.com.

If you want to get an idea of how out-of-control soaring CEO pay has gotten, it's important to look at the CEO pay of America's automakers. To me, Detroit sums up many of the major problems that America's economy as a whole faces these days.

Detroit's CEOs have long pocketed by far the highest compensation levels of any auto executives in the world.

This shouldn't really be surprising: American CEOs in general have long raked in vastly higher pay packages than their overseas counterparts. U.S. CEOs make, on average, 22 times what their counterparts make in Japan and 17 times what their counterparts earn in Europe.

If pay is somehow tied to performance, then you'd think that America's automakers are the world's most competitive, correct?

If so, you'd be wrong. Detroit, in fact, has been steadily losing market share to foreign automakers for the past five decades. And the blame for this can be laid squarely on the shoulders of Detroit's CEOs, who've made one stupid decision after another for decades. One recent example: Detroit's decision to stake everything on gas-guzzling SUVs, while the Japanese were busy perfecting hybrid technology. (Hybrids are currently by far the auto industry's hottest segment).

Detroit CEOs have long complained that "it's not their fault" and have offered up one excuse after another as to why America's car companies are losing market share. My favorite excuse of theirs is that foreign automakers' workers earn less than their America counterparts (an excuse that the U.S. mainstream and business media has never bothered to challenge).

A quick look at the numbers explodes this lie. The fact is, automaker employees in both Japan and Germany earn higher salaries than U.S. automaker workers do these days. Japan's wages run 30 to 40 percent higher than Detroit's wages. And German automakers workers earn around $49/hour on average versus $39/hour for Detroit's workers.

Although U.S. automaker workers earn less than their foreign counterparts, Detroit CEOs make vastly higher pay packages than their counterparts do in Germany or Japan.

This vast gulf was vividly demonstrated in 1998 when German automaker Daimler-Benz took over U.S. automaker Chrysler. As it turned out, the CEO of Daimler-Benz, Jurgen Schrempp, was earning a pay package that was less than one-tenth of the pay package of Chrysler CEO Robert Eaton.

One might think, given the gigantic pay packages of America's CEOs these days, that being a chief executive is a demanding job. It seems to me that the opposite is true. CEOs seem to do little more these days than bitch and moan and offer up excuses for their companies' declining fortunes. There are always plenty of handy scapegoats around. Unions. Democrats. "Excessive" red tape and regulations. Lower wages overseas. Ad nauseam.

It seems to me that, far from having a difficult job, America's CEOs actually have one of the easiest jobs in the world these days. When things aren't going well, simply blame others for your mistakes (shades of the Bush White House here). And, if that doesn't work, simply ask for another round of corporate welfare from the government.

Saturday, April 23, 2005

Time Magazine's GOP-Friendly Bias Nothing New

By MARC MCDONALD

Outraged progressive commentators across the Web are asking their visitors to cancel their subscriptions to Time magazine in the aftermath of that magazine's puff piece on fascist nutcase Ann Coulter.

The Time April 25 cover story offended progressives (and, for that matter, all sane Americans) with writer John Cloud's contention that he "didn't find many outright Coulter errors."
This, despite the fact that Coulter's vicious hatemongering is absolutely smothered with blatant lies that have been extensively documented in print media and across the Web.

While many progressives are angered by this whole episode, I think it's actually good news for American public discourse.

I think it's great that progressives are finally starting to see Time magazine for what it really is. A jingoistic, right-leaning, anti-union, business-friendly publication that masquerades as "unbiased" serious journalism. A magazine that gave acres of coverage to the partisan witchhunt against Clinton and then snoozed through critical stories like GOP's stealing of the 2000 election and the disenfranchisement of Ohio voters in 2004.

There are those of us who've been shouting from the rooftops for years that Time leans Republican. Now, it appears the Left will finally take notice. And hopefully, more than a few progressives will cancel their subscriptions.

To get an understanding of Time magazine's conservative leanings, it's important to take a look at the magazine's history, which has always been steadily pro-business and pro-GOP since launching in 1923.

Before that, founders Henry Luce and Briton Hadden were noted for having turned their college paper (the Yale Daily News) into a "propagandist sheet promoting intense patriotism" during World War I (according to "The People's Almanac" by David Wallechinsky and Irving Wallace).

"The People's Almanac" documents Time magazine's historically conservative bias, including the magazine's take on events when the U.S. was in the grip of hard times during the 1930s economic meltdown:

"The Depression would go away if one worked and prayed hard enough, and if some people starved, well, it was pretty much their own fault. Luce never had any sympathy for losers."

Time later propagandized for the U.S. to enter World War II, "The People's Almanac" notes. But not for the purpose of saving democracy, or the British, but to establish American dominance in the world:

This was to be, Luce said, the "American Century." America must take charge of the world because no one else was worthy. Military supremacy was essential.

Time magazine's pro-GOP leanings continued after the war, "The People's Almanac" notes. "By 1950 Time had become almost the house organ of the Republican party."

Despite Time magazine's historically pro-Republican leanings, I'm a bit baffled as to why it would dignify human filth like Coulter. I suppose it all comes down to profit. After all, the mainstream media's embrace of "unbiased" news has really always been about profit.

If you claim to be unbiased, then, in theory this will increase readership and boost your profits. It sounds like a plausible theory on paper. But the fact is, I think this approach has finally caught up with America's mainstream press.

Big Media's credibility is lower than ever these days. The Right has long condemned the media for a supposed "liberal" bias. And now the Left is also starting to catch on that Big Media is not to be trusted.

The bottom line is that the corporate media titans these days are dinosaurs and headed for extinction. With the rise of the Internet, the media is splintering into thousands of independent voices, that corporate America (much to its horror) cannot control. Across the Web, tens of thousands of online publications are emerging and few of them make any ridiculous pretense at "non-partisanship."

Time shot itself in the foot with the Coulter fiasco. And Big Media's loss is a big plus for all of us who believe in putting the truth (and people) before profits.

Tuesday, April 19, 2005

New Pope's Homeland Could Teach GOP a Thing or Two About Christian Values

By MARC MCDONALD

I'm not sure I have an opinion on the selection of Joseph Ratzinger as the new pope. But I do have an opinion about the pope's homeland, Germany.

Germany is not a perfect nation by any means. And it has a horrific past. But I think in the overall balance of things, Germany is a more Christian nation than the U.S. is today. This, despite the fact that the overwhelming majority of Germans (like most Europeans) are secular, and don't attend church.

How can this possibly be, you might be asking? Well, first of all, I should explain what I mean by "Christian."

A big part of the problem I've always had with the Christian religion is not the teachings of Christ (most of which I wholeheartedly agree with). It's "Christians" themselves.

At least here in the U.S., Christianity has been twisted, perverted and distorted by Bible-thumping fundamentalists (who ironically seem to be completely ignorant of the Bible's contents).

I've never understood why the Republicans, of all people, have long been identified as the party somehow closest to Christian values and morals. I'm not sure what Bible these people are referring to. A great deal of what animates them seems to consist of issues that aren't even mentioned in the Scriptures.

Abortion, for one thing. "Christians" will rant and rave all day about this topic---which is odd, because abortion is not mentioned once in the Bible.

What's equally strange is that when I read the Bible (particularly the words of Christ himself), I find myself in total agreement---and I'm a diehard progressive.

I agree with the Bible verse, Mark 10:21. This is a verse that describes what happens when a wealthy man approaches Christ and asks him what he must do to "inherit eternal life."

Christ responds, "You lack one thing; go, sell what you have, and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven."

Note that Christ does not say that one must sell one's possessions and give to the poor in order to simply be a "good Christian." Instead, he says we must do this if we want to go to heaven, period.

This is one of those Bible verses you'll never, ever hear Republicans mention. Instead, Republicans are always busy digging deep into the Old Testament (which, incidentally, Christ said his own words replaced) and finding obscure verses to support their views on issues like homosexuality. Never mind the fact that the Old Testament is FULL of bizarre stories and teachings that I'm not sure that anyone today really fathoms. I mean, how about the verse that says that a man who has damaged testicles may not enter a temple to worship?

Christ spent a lot of his ministry speaking harshly of the wealthy. In fact, he only has kind words for two groups of people: children and the poor.

Which brings me back to my original topic. Germany is a country that has policies that send shivers down the spine (or lack thereof) of Republicans. For one thing, Germany has an extensive social welfare system and a huge array of programs to help poor and lower-income people that would simply be inconceivable in the U.S. As a result, the sort of wretched, bottom-of-the-barrel poverty that is widespread in the U.S. is simply unheard of in Germany (and, indeed, most European nations).

One in every five children in America lives in poverty. The comparable figure for Germany is less than one-tenth the U.S. rate. Given Christ's views on the poor and children, I'd suspect that if Jesus returned today, he would look more favorably on Germany than the U.S.

Surprisingly, for a nation that has the third-largest economy in the world, Germany doesn't get a lot of detailed coverage in the U.S. media. Most Americans are pretty ignorant about what goes on there. What's more, the U.S. media's coverage of German affairs tends to be highly distorted and often flat-out wrong.

The vast majority of U.S. media coverage about Germany these days seems to consist of gloom-and-doom stories that talk endlessly about Germany's economic woes. (Inevitably, these same stories always go on to say that Germany is working to abolish its generous social welfare programs and is embracing the U.S. model of rough-and-tumble capitalism).

The U.S. media's coverage of Germany is in fact highly flawed. Take, for example, Germany's economic problems. It's simply not true to say that Germany is in some sort of economic crisis. Germany does have a jobless rate higher than that of the U.S. But the fact is, this has little to do with any fundamental problems with the nation's economic system.

The fact is, Germany historically had an extremely low jobless rate for over half a century after World War II. It was only when reunification arrived that the nation's unemployment rate soared. When Germany reunited, the wealthy West went into the much poorer East Germany and shuttered thousands of inefficient state-owned businesses, which caused millions to lose their jobs.

For over a decade, Germany has been spending hundreds of billions of dollars modernizing the East and working to bring it up to the level of the West. It's been a painful, drawn-out process. But the U.S. media is simply not telling the truth when it repeatedly insists that Germany's current woes stem from some sort of fundamental structural flaws in its economic system (and that the nation must embrace the U.S. model).

Incidentally, there is more than meets the eye with Germany's jobless rate. For a start, being jobless in Germany isn't quite a disaster that it can be in the U.S. Germany, for example, has generous social welfare programs that make it possible to live relatively comfortably, even if one is jobless.

American economists and Republicans are always touting the U.S. economic system's "superiority" by pointing out that we have a low jobless rate. I find it interesting, though, that these pundits never mention that the U.S. has the largest prison population in the world, with over 2 million people behind bars. That's a vastly higher incarceration rate than Germany, by the way.

Germany is a country that gets endless grief from U.S. conservative pundits and economic commentators. The latter constantly deride Germany's "bloated and excessive" welfare and social programs. They also condemn the German economic system as being "shackled" by all kinds of supposedly unnecessary red tape and regulation.

Publications like "The Wall Street Journal" constantly criticize Germany as a sinking economic power whose only salvation is, of course, a hefty dose of American-style brutal dog-eat-dog capitalism. One recent editorial in the "Journal" confidently (and arrogantly) predicted that the latter will indeed eventually occur and that Germany's guaranteed 6-week paid vacations for all workers will be the sort of thing that German school children "read about in history books one day."

Frankly, I don't see any of this happening myself. The fact is, Germans (and Europeans in general) long ago took a good, hard look at the American economic model and rejected it. The whole idea that Germany is ready to embrace American style capitalism is a fantasy. And it certainly doesn't take into account the German people themselves who have shown (like other Europeans) that they won't hesitate to take to the streets and rally in massive protests to defend their hard-won rights.

But I think a more fundamental question is this: does Germany really need to change its system at all? And for that matter, is Germany really the economic basket case that is portrayed in the U.S. media?

The answer is: absolutely not. It's time to take a look at just how powerful the German economy is today.

For a start, Germany is the world's largest exporter. That's right: Germany exports more than even China does. In fact, Germany has been the world's top exporter for most of the past five decades.

It's remarkable that Germany, with less than one-third America's population, is able to out-export the U.S. But even this doesn't tell the full story. The fact is, Germany's exports by and large consist of highly-sophisticated, capital-intensive products, ranging from machine tools to advanced chemicals to automobiles. By contrast, America's export numbers these days are heavily padded by the simple raw commodities that comprise much of our exports: items like timber, agriculture products and iron ore. Ominously for America, the latter are the sort of exports that Third World nations have long been known for.

Nor is Germany particularly under threat from the rise of China (unlike the U.S., which is currently in the midst of a panic attack over China's growing flood of exports). The fact is, Germany, along with Japan, has long specialized in the sort of sophisticated, capital-intensive products that have enormous entry barriers to would-be competitors. In short, despite its rapid rise, China is a long, long ways away from producing anything on the level of, say, a Porsche sports car.

For all the talk about China's rise to prominence, the fact remains that that nation is still heavily dependent on advanced manufacturing powerhouses like Germany to supply it with the building blocks of industrialization, (like factory production equipment and machine tools). Despite the fact that it floods the U.S. with exports, China actually runs an overall trade deficit these days.

Despite Germany's economic sophistication, many American commentors are always rambling on about how the U.S. is supposedly the world's "most competitive" nation. This makes me wonder what they could possibly mean by the word "competitive." The U.S. has the largest trade deficits of any nation in history. It seems to me that we're having a tough time making products that other nations wish to buy these days. So I really wonder how anyone could call us "competitive" at all.

Besides its export prowess, Germany shines in other ways as well these days. The nation has one of the world's strongest currencies in the Euro. And Germany is one of the largest capital exporters in the world (hardly the sign of a "weak" economy). Last but not least, the Germans are among the most highly paid workers in the world, (trailing only Switzerland).

Germany is also a vastly more egalitarian society than the U.S. The enormous (and growing) divide between rich and poor that plagues the U.S. simply doesn't exist in Germany. And Germany also gives a much higher percentage of its GNP to poor countries than the stingy U.S. does.

Let me see: an egalitarian nation that takes care of its poor people. A nation with generous social welfare programs. A nation that gives generously to poor countries. A nation that takes a leading role in world environmental issues and long ago abolished capital punishment.

Somehow, I get the feeling that if Christ returned today, he would look more favorably upon Germany than the U.S., a country that ignores its poor, lies to its people, embraces the death penalty, and celebrates gluttony and greed.

Friday, April 15, 2005

When Poor People Start Wishing They Were Rich

By MARC McDONALD

Tax season is here again. Would you like to know a sure-fire way of reducing your tax bill?

Simple. Become rich. The richer, the better.

Example: let's say your wealth puts you in the top 1/100th of 1 percent of all Americans. That's about 28,000 people in the U.S. These people, on average, make around $2 million every five days, which is what the average American earns over the course of a lifetime.

The tax burden for these super-rich people has been steadily falling for years. For example, in 1993, they paid 30 cents of every dollar into federal income tax. In 2000, that had fallen to 22 cents. Now, with the Bush tax cuts, it has fallen to 18 cents.

In his book Perfectly Legal, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist David Cay Johnston details an outrageously unfair tax system that screws the poor and working class. It's a tax system that has been increasing shifting the burden away from the rich and onto lower-income tax payers for years, a phenomenon that's gotten little coverage in the mainstream media.

Not only do the rich avoid paying taxes, but they also usually avoid tax audits. Johnston points out that working class people are eight times more likely to face an audit than the wealthy.

Johnston is only one of a number of high-profile investigative journalists who've detailed America's unfair tax system over the years.

In 1994, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalists Donald Barlett and James Steele published an eye-opening account of America's unfair tax system in their book, America: Who Really Pays the Taxes?

Barlett and Steele painted a gloomy picture of a beleaguered middle- and working class that is soaking up more and more of the nation's tax burden. They also detail how the tax burden is quietly shifting in other ways.

For example, the tax burden in the U.S. over the years has been shifting from corporations to individual tax payers. In the 1950s, corporations paid around half of all taxes. Today, their burden has shrunk to less than 10 percent. In fact, today, 60 percent of all U.S. corporations pay zero income tax.

Johnston, Bartlett and Steele point out numerous cases in which wealthy individuals don't even bother to file a tax return.

Johnston cites the example of two billionaires, Alec and Jocelyn Wildenstein, who admitted under oath that for 30 years, they never even filed a tax return---and faced no consequences as a result.

In their book, Barlett and Steele point out that in 1989, there were 1,081 people earning over $200,000 who paid zero income tax. I would suspect that since Barlett and Steele's 1994 book was released that the number of wealthy tax avoiders has increased further still.

In the interviews they conducted to research their books, Barlett, Steele and Johnston describe ordinary tax payers' seething anger and frustration with the unfairness of the tax code.

Johnston, in particular, seems pessimistic that the U.S. tax system will ever be fixed. He considers open revolt and social disruption a possibility in the future.

For their part, Barlett and Steele, offer modest proposals for making the tax system more equitable, such as closing all loopholes. However, the odds of real change to make the tax system more fair in Bush's America seem remote indeed.

Monday, March 28, 2005

How the U.S. Media Exaggerates America's Economic Strengths

By MARC McDONALD

Right-wingers are constantly blasting the U.S. media these days, charging that it is driven by a "liberal" agenda. Of course, such charges cause progressives to laugh out loud.

Conservatives believe they are insulting the media when they accuse it of a liberal bias. In reality, such charges actually dignify what the media does these days.

The fact is, it's impossible for the mainstream media to have a political bias unless it actually covers real news stories with substance.

A glance at today's mainstream media indicates that the press falls short on this count. Instead, the media is dominated by cheap, sleazy, sensational "news," instead of covering issues of real substance.

On the increasingly rare occasions when the media does cover issues of substance, it often falls short of serious, objective journalism.

I believe that most people these days, including many educated progressives, are unaware of just how distorted the "serious" media is on many issues.

One issue that has gotten zero coverage in the press is how the media tends to exaggerate the strength of America's
economy these days.

And one of the major ways the media exaggerates America's economic prospects is via the widespread usage of
a bizarre economic statistic called "purchasing power parity" (PPP) in its coverage of the U.S. and the global economy.

PPP is a yardstick that has been used almost exclusively by the U.S. media since around 1985.

Up until that time, the media simply used the current values from the world's currency markets---a much more logical and
honest approach.

(Interestingly enough, the mid-1980s was also a period during which other nations, including Japan and Germany, began
overtaking the U.S. in per capita income levels for the first time).

Although at first glance, it might seem like PPP is an obscure topic, best left to specialized economic
journals, the truth is the exact opposite.

In a nutshell, the media's use of PPP misleads the American public about a number of important issues,
not least of which is that it gives the public an exaggerated sense of U.S. economic clout these days.

If you look at any story these days in the media that discusses issues like American GDP or U.S. income levels,
the PPP figure is always used.

As a result, most Americans are under the impression that per capital U.S. income levels are the highest
in the world. (In reality, the U.S. is surpassed by 12 other nations in per capita income these days).

PPP is basically an artificial creation of economists. It simply does not exist in the real world.

Many economists believe that the U.S. dollar is unfairly valued by world currency markets. Thus, under PPP, (as an
an example) they assign a value of 140 yen to one dollar, instead of the true market value of 104 yen/dollar. This would be not that big a deal were PPP relegated to obscure academic journals.

But virtually all U.S. mainstream media outlets these days rely solely on PPP values when they discuss issues like U.S. GDP
or income levels.

This is highly misleading to the American public. For a start, it gives the impression that U.S. economic strength is much
stronger than it really is. Another problem is the fact that few, if any readers, understand exactly what PPP is, or how
it is calculated.

A final major problem is that readers are completely unaware that the figures they see in the media are vastly inflating the value of the dollar.

One major irony in economists' embrace of PPP is that it is an artificial creation. I find it bizarre that economists (who're always rambling on about the supposed perfection of the "free market") reject the market's own value for the dollar these days.

Another irony is that, far from being overvalued, as PPP advocates argue, currencies like the yen are actually greatly
undervalued these days. (The Bank of Japan does its best to suppress the value of the yen by buying billions of dollars
in world currency markets).

The time has come for the U.S. mainstream media to stop misleading its readers about the strength of today's U.S. economy.
For starters, the media needs to examine the following issues:

1. What, exactly, is PPP and how is it calculated? Is this methodology flawed? (A growing number of dissident
economists believe this is indeed the case).

2. Why does the U.S. media rely solely on PPP when it discusses issues like U.S. GDP and income levels?

3. When including PPP figures, shouldn't the media inform its readers that PPP artificially inflates the value of the
dollar?

4. When including PPP figures in a story or a chart, shouldn't the media, for balance, also include world currency market values for the dollar?

5. Indeed, is it not highly misleading to readers for the media not to do the above?

Friday, January 28, 2005

Crichton's Right-Wing Screed "State of Fear" is Full of Hot Air

By MARC McDONALD

Like Rush Limbaugh, Michael Crichton is not an environmental scientist. However, he's read some books on the topic and he feels he knows enough to belittle the efforts of thousands of scientists worldwide who've been studying the problem of global warming for decades.

In his popular novel, State of Fear, right-wing author Crichton assures us that these scientists, along with the world's environmental groups, are misguided, hysterical alarmists.

It's interesting, though: those are the same accusations that conservatives hurled at the makers of the film, The China Syndrome, upon its 1979 release.

However, the conservatives suddenly fell silent when, a mere 13 days after the movie's release, the nation watched in horror as the Three Mile Island reactor experienced a partial core meltdown (which came close to rendering the state of Pennsylvania uninhabitable for 10,000 years).

State of Fear presents a scary scenario in which evil, extremist environmental groups conspire to advance their agenda by triggering man-made disasters like tsunamis, which they then intend to blame on global warming.

Crichton thinks the fears over global warming are baseless and he's concerned that we risk spending unnecessary money to prevent it, or by signing silly treaties like the Kyoto Protocol.

Now, as a taxpayer, I'm all for not spending money on unnecessary programs. For example, I question whether it was really necessary for the U.S. to spend trillions of dollars on nuclear arms during the Cold War. And I wonder if it's really wise for the Bush White House to be spending a quarter trillion dollars on a missile defense system that many top scientists say will never work.

But I really have to wonder if spending on anti-global warming efforts is "wasted" money, as Crichton asserts. After all, as Crichton himself admits, the science of global warming is far from certain. And personally, I think we owe it to our
children to err on the side of caution on this issue.

Having said that, I think it's odd that Crichton aims to debunk global warming in this book. I have to wonder what his agenda is. Is it, perhaps, an effort to discourage the U.S. public from supporting the Kyoto Protocol?

If that's the case, it's not the environmentalists, but Crichton himself, who is the paranoid alarmist.

The fact is, the U.S. long ago completely rejected Kyoto, a treaty that has been signed by 180 other nations. And given the fact that the Bush White House get its environmental policy from the same mega-corporations that cause our nation's
environmental woes, I don't think Crichton needs to lose any sleep over the U.S. signing Kyoto any time soon.

Like all Crichton thrillers, State of Fear features evil, menacing bad guys. I'm sure this posed a challenge for Crichton when he sat down to write the book. After all, it's hard to imagine how one could demonize America's environmental groups, which are comprised of millions of ordinary concerned citizens, volunteering their time and money.

In Crichton's hands, though, the nation's environmental groups turn into devious, sinister monsters, who don't hesitate to plot disasters to kill thousands of innocent people, simply to advance their agenda.

If Crichton really believe America's environmental groups would be willing to plot mass murder, then he's a sadly deluded and paranoid individual. Which is ironic, given that he spends the whole book accusing environmentalists of being deluded and paranoid.

Defenders of Crichton will point out that he must be correct, as he includes loads of references from scientific journals that seemingly support his ideas in State of Fear.

However, in assessing State of Fear, I think it's important to take a look at Crichton's past track record, which is frankly dismal.

For example, in 1992, Crichton released Rising Sun, a jingoistic book that predicted that the mighty Japanese economic juggernaut was on the verge of overwhelming the world and relegating America to the status of a backwater economic colony.

History hasn't been kind to Rising Sun. For the past 13 years, Japan has been mired in economic doldrums and a never-ending recession.

The fact is that, even if global warming is bunk, there are manyreasons why America needs to wean itself off of fossil fuels. After all, oil is a finite resource and the world's supplies are steadily dwindling. And given that America has to import vast quantities of oil from the unstable, dangerous Middle East is alone enough justification for our nation to be exploring ways to cut our oil consumption.

Outside of his loony right-wing fantasy of environmental groups plotting mass murder, Crichton doesn't really have much to say about the "harm" of spending money to address global warming (outside of claiming that it's money wasted). Which is ironic when you consider that the vast sums that we're spending in places like Iraq could go a long ways toward converting our nation over to solar and wind power. As it is, while the U.S. is spending $200 billion on the never-ending, bloody Iraqi quagmire, other nations like Germany and Japan have decisively taken the lead in solar and wind power and the technology gap is widening, year by year.